Consumer contact NJPAIP phone number assigned risk auto insurance. Confidential NJ PAIP Car Insurance Online Help. NJ PAIP phone number for consumer advice – nonstandard or high risk auto insurance quotes and coverages. Consumer Help And Rate Quotes (856) 352-2101 This is not the number for claims, assignments or producer questions. Call Administrative Plan Office instead. NJPAIP-New Jersey High Risk Auto Insurance Consumer Help Phone Number.